gamers
Report a problem

Germany Seeks Common EU Rules on Violent Video Games

Slimy   on 17 January 2007 - 16:57 · 15 comments & 5875 views

Advertisement (Why?)
Germany took over the six month rotating presidency of the Union at the beginning of January. The European Commission is pushing to standardize rules for more control over video game violence throughout the 27 countries in the Union.

“A certain degree of linkage between the growing violence among the younger generation and the growing diffusion of violent games exists. Protection of children cannot have borders,” said Franco Frattini, the European Justice commissioner.

Minimum age rules on certain titles and outright bans on the most violent games are under consideration. The German government plans to conduct a study of all the different national rules concerning video games. Judging by recent events in Germany regarding violent video games, the government has previously proposed a national law banning games that depict violence toward human characters, bans are fairly likely.

Although the Interactive Software Federation of Europe has opposed bans of any kind in the past, the group has recently announced they supports Frattini’s efforts to protect children. They believe an age-rating system is a solid idea.

News source: InfoWorld

Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 15 additional comments
#1 Bosaka on 17 Jan 2007 - 17:28
Guess they should make networked TV's and music players that you have to enter a unique id number of the person or biometrics to censor violent lyrics and violent shows too.
#2 Wolfsglen on 17 Jan 2007 - 17:31
With all due respect, bugger off Politicians. And pick up a history book while yer at it, these guys may be shocked to learn that violence and killing existed for several thousand/million years before computer games came into being, and it will still exist even if computer games are totally excised from existance at all. Perhaps they should visit some violent genocidal parts of the planet that have never seen a video game in their entire life.

If certain elements of the german government wish to do SWAT style armed raids on game companies making violent games, and blanket ban a select few games even for adults, then that is entirely their insane and idiotic business...but dont expect the rest of us to follow suit.

At this rate people will get so bored of being wrapped up in teletubby happy-joy-joy niceness overload 24/7 they will end up going beserk and psycho more from that than they ever will a game!
#3 Krysys on 17 Jan 2007 - 19:42
Yikes! Being a gamer in the uk, im not impressed! Germany's ideas on video games are extreme to say the least. I just hope they keep them to themselves. I still feel sorry for german gamers.
#4 chicken-royal on 17 Jan 2007 - 19:48
I think, generally, age restrictions are a good thing. Games like Doom 3, San Andreas etc shouldn't really be played by anyone under 16/18 (I guess the 18 rating in the UK makes it easier to tell if someone is old enough to buy it - its easier to look over 16 than it is 18, generally). Yes, I know people under 18 will still get the game, but at least there is some warning to the adult buying it.

However, banning games completely is wrong. It suppresses freedom of speech and choice.

I'm all for age ratings on games, but I'm strongly opposed of games being banned!
#5 Guyro on 17 Jan 2007 - 20:43
nooooo were turnin communist losing our freedom to play games
#6 Nose Nuggets on 17 Jan 2007 - 22:20
every day this crap is allowed to stand is a day we draw closer to a life like that depicted in Equilibrium (Christian Bale movie). age restrictions should be MORE then enough. Alcohol and vehicles cause more deaths then video games, but alas, a simple age restriction is all that stands. ill tell you what, if more politicians played video games we would never even hear about this stuff. how about we make the parents do some damn parenting?

stop the world, i want to get off.

#7 The_Decryptor on 18 Jan 2007 - 03:55
I don't have an issue with age restrictions, I'm all for them (we have a very bad enforced age restriction over here, no games can be for over 18 year olds, i desperately want to see a sane system replace it).

The rest of it is stupid though.
(1 reply) #8 Nose Nuggets on 18 Jan 2007 - 04:25
where are you The_Decryptor?
#8.1 Islander on 18 Jan 2007 - 10:43
Edit: Sorry, wrong button.
(1 reply) #9 Islander on 18 Jan 2007 - 10:45
German politicians are just a bit stupid, that's all. They don't want to see those problem come from education failing and social problems (related to crappy national politics), and need to find ANY excuse so they can win the next elections too, that's it basically. It's a nightmare, and poor german people have been suffering under those idiots for years now. Where's the law that forbids lame politicians ?
#9.1 Seismo on 18 Jan 2007 - 17:31
Quote - (Islander said @ #9)
German politicians are just a bit stupid, that's all. They don't want to see those problem come from education failing and social problems (related to crappy national politics), and need to find ANY excuse so they can win the next elections too, that's it basically. It's a nightmare, and poor german people have been suffering under those idiots for years now. Where's the law that forbids lame politicians ?


Sad, but so true. They all need to be replaced.
#10 Bamsebjørn on 18 Jan 2007 - 15:11
I hate the European Union more and more every day...
(2 replies) #11 on 01 Jan 1970 - 00:00
#11.1 Nose Nuggets on 18 Jan 2007 - 19:11
Quote - (Guest said @ #10)
but then we live in a global society where the average person is dumb, greedy and out to have fun regardless of other peoples expense.


damn, you must think its just hopeless. the average person is out to have fun regardless of others? if that where true it would be absolute chaos. regardless of video games.

Quote -
The problem is, sometimes situations occur and tempers rise, then people lose sight of the penalties of why they dont do these things, and so they do them anyway.
in a situation where tempers rise and people loose sight of penalties and the law, they usualy dont start thinking about video games. how about we get some laws in place that force parents to do a little parenting instead of blaming there little jimmys g4ngsta killing spree on a video game that hundreds of thousands of people play.

i think its ludicrous that you think
Quote -
1 persons life is a worthy sacrafice for millions to have entertainment.

especially considering the circumstances. the people who kill and then blame it on video games are screwed up people. only a person with deep, deep issues could somehow misconstrue the content of a video game to relate in any way to real life. or they are very young and simply not capable of separating reality and fantasy yet.

this is supposed to be a free country. i pay taxes, i obey the law. how in the world can anyone have the right to tell me i cant play a video game in my house. and if you can where does it end? i should be able to do anything i want in my own home as long as it does not directly effect anyone else. i should be able to watch violent films, or play violent video games, or clean my guns, or drink boose, or smoke grass and shoot heroin. and if so inclined, do it with my gay lover if he chooses to participate. people need to get the idea out of there head that they can somehow control people and 'protect' people by restricting what i do with my free private time.
#11.2 +badger face on 19 Jan 2007 - 15:07
"damn, you must think its just hopeless. the average person is out to have fun regardless of others? if that where true it would be absolute chaos. regardless of video games."

well the doomsday clock is nearing midnight for a reason. If you have ever played a game like halo or gears of war the sort of trash talking people come out with on regular occasions is specifically said to upset people all because of a video game. you get racial slurs, slurs on your family, your life, and your country (if you are from anywhere other than the US) and they do it because they think it is funny and dont care how the other person is affected.

"in a situation where tempers rise and people loose sight of penalties and the law, they usualy dont start thinking about video games. how about we get some laws in place that force parents to do a little parenting "

Thats not what i was suggesting, i was suggesting that video games can have a subconscious lasting affect on your life. It can make you a more "..." person. It could make you happier? It could make you more confident. Or less confident. Or more angry - and thats the point. But sure i am all for enforcing some parenting laws. i think you should pass a test to have kids buts thats just me

"only a person with deep, deep issues could somehow misconstrue the content of a video game to relate in any way to real life. or they are very young and simply not capable of separating reality and fantasy yet."

Thats the point. There are 6 billion people in the world, i suspect a lot of people fall into those catagories.

"people need to get the idea out of there head that they can somehow control people and 'protect' people by restricting what i do with my free private time."

The arguement isnt to stop you playing certain video games, it is to stop them being made in the first place, which is a valid arguement. I dont think a games developer should be able to do whatever they want, they shouldnt be allowed to incite racial hatred for example, so you need to draw a line somewhere, and i think pimping hoes, killing people stealing cars drugs etc. all crosses the line. If it were just one, in a reasonable context, it wouldnt be so bad. Its because GTA is only about breaking the law that it gets a lot of bad press.

Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!

Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.

Advertisement (Why?)